asylum seekers maga Maine Post racism tax dollars

Catherynne Valente schools her racist neighbors about the asylum seekers in their midst / Boing Boing

[Author Catherynne Valente (previously) posted this outstanding rant to her Facebook page; I asked her permission to repost it here so it would have somewhere to live outside of the zuckerverse and she graciously gave her permission -Cory]

I stay in Portland, Maine. We’ve got lately had an inflow of African asylum seekers and the city has been scrambling to seek out shelter and help for them.

Cue NextDoor, that wretched hive of scum and villainy. Each day someone would submit some new hateful jingoistic nonsense about how horrible these individuals are and that they should get out of ‘Merica and depart it to the ‘Mericans.

I attempt to not become involved on NextDoor as a result of I reside in a small group and I have to see these individuals at the ferry dock. However I acquired mad. And I obtained involved. And it obtained lengthy.

So I decided to share it with you. Please be happy to share it with others who may want to listen to it.


You understand, I was going to let this thread go by without saying anything. It’s not value it, I stated to myself. These individuals aren’t going to pay attention. But y’all can’t stop being hateful and I’m uninterested in getting notifications that someone else is being and absolute bell-end about their fellow man on NextDoor.

So buckle up.

To start with, “they” aren’t illegal. They’re asylum seekers. It’s legal in each nation on the planet to hunt asylum, and they are abiding by the regulation. Identical to our good friend together with his grandfather’s naturalization certificates at the prime of the thread (which is from 1928, by the bloody method, predating the Hart-Cellar Act of 1965 which utterly overhauled the course of to enter this country, particularly to make it more durable for minorities because human beings will hold a rock as a pet however can’t consider different human beings as brothers until they appear *precisely* like them. And even then). THEY NEED HELP BECAUSE THEY ARE FOLLOWING THE LAW. The regulation forbids them to work for six months after entry. In the event that they have been illegal, they might just start working considered one of the many menial jobs that haven’t any drawback hiring underpaid immigrant labor.

Second, these individuals are not hurting you. In any means. I might be shocked if anybody yelling about those terrible no good very dangerous fellow human beings had ever met even one in every of them. Lots of them are educated and skilled. Lots of them are Francophones, making Maine an exquisite place for them to reestablish themselves, as there are nonetheless pockets of French audio system in this state. Each single research exhibits that immigrants and asylum seekers are a internet profit to the financial system, that they get off of social providers much quicker than homegrown welfare recipients, that they turn into entrepreneurs and arduous staff. And but you hate them before they even arrive.

And if you wish to speak to me about how a few of them are Muslim, and may deliver their naughty repressive Muslim African culture into fantastic, flawless liberal America, let me inform you about Alabama. And Georgia. And Ohio. And North Carolina. And the Supreme Courtroom. The people who are proper now actively in search of to curtail my rights to my own physique, to stop me from voting for my own equal illustration, to empower the corporations which will employ me over myself, are as American as the flag, fireworks, and goddamned apple pie. These are particular person individuals with no institutional energy, and you haven’t any concept what they assume or consider about something because you don’t know them. The individuals with institutional energy are hurting us all. Right now. And I don’t see any indignant threads on Next Door about it.

OMG BUT MY TAXES.

I. Pay. Taxes. Too. And my taxes go to help an growing older Maine inhabitants, to provide them healthcare, food stamps, housing subsidies, social safety, and myriad other avenues of help. Help that may virtually definitely not be obtainable to me when I am previous, because the very era receiving my tax dollars has repeatedly voted for the downsizing and existential dissolution of the packages they take pleasure in. Yet I nonetheless pay. I pay for you. Figuring out I’ll get nothing in return.

However you recognize what actually pisses me off about the place my tax dollars go? It isn’t that they help an getting older conservative inhabitants with the free time to publish countless hateful multi-exclamation point capslocked screeds on the Web. And it goddamn nicely isn’t that 86-150 families (god, how few human beings it takes to activate the histrionics) who’ve been by means of the most heinous and unimaginable cruelty, violence, and persecution may settle right here in this state the place all the young individuals truly born listed here are fleeing at rates that might snap your neck.

My tax dollars and your tax dollars and all of our tax dollars are going to build a megayacht dock in Portland in order that extra uber-rich assholes have a place to park their large pleasure boats, boats that value greater than these 86-150 families might ever want.

My tax dollars and your tax dollars and all of our tax dollars are going to subsidize developers who odor recent meat in our city to allow them to construct more luxurious condos none of us can afford (and again, the sale worth of three or 4 of them on the West End would cowl every thing these households need), condos that may sit empty for all however two weeks a yr so that a number of families can take a look at the water and stuff themselves with lobster butter while complaining about stay music to the level that our festivals get cancelled to allow them to go to bed earlier, murmuring as they drift off to a dreamland none of us could make a down cost on that Portland was so a lot better in the previous days.

My tax dollars and your tax dollars and all of our tax dollars have, for eight years, gone toward blocking payments the individuals voted for from turning into regulation, preventing in the courts to not give Mainers medicare or increase our minimum wage or allow us to smoke in peace or have a bit of extra selection in voting. Our cash has gone to subsidizing pink states that hate New England like hearth. Our cash has gone to making positive the megayacht-parking lobster butter bathers pay less in taxes than a barista on Munjoy Hill. And NONE of you’re complaining about that.

Nor do I see any single thread trying to assist the homeless vets and addicts you’re all all of a sudden so conveniently involved about, regardless of how dangerous the winter gets. Pro tip: don’t use veterans as strawmen once you argue that the poor deserve nothing and America is by some means full. An enormous proportion of vets are immigrants themselves, and they are on the market defending your right to be a complete dick on the internet.

One way or the other, for some strange cause, the solely time individuals seem to take to their keyboards to complain about the place their taxes are going is once they may simply find yourself serving to somebody much less fortunate. Once they help individuals more fortunate? Crickets.

This state is ageing. We’d like a brand new tax base or all those senior citizens will endure, because their providers will probably be reduce with out individuals my age to pay for them. Young individuals are not shifting here. They’re simply vacationing right here. Should you feel like freezing to demise some idle winter with out social providers still yelling Don’t Tread On Me, be my visitor. I would like to stay in a vigorous multicultural city filled with art, music, food, theater, and extra providers being used by individuals who need them to survive than those that simply need to pay rather less taxes and have a handy place to park their yachts.

The hate in this thread is repulsive. You must all be ashamed of yourselves. I might imagine a few of you think about yourselves Christian, even when you spit on those Christ commanded you to shelter and treat whilst you’d him. Nice work. There’s not one in every of you who has not taken help from one other human being sooner or later in your lives, even if it’s solely in the form of using the roads and electrical energy and infrastructure we all pay for collectively to make yourselves a hit. Filling these individuals’s bellies costs us a lot lower than filling the insatiable gullets of the vulture capitalists that have made quite the little feast of our metropolis in the last decade. It’s completely pathetic that we should pay for the rich to hurt us, but that rouses no protest, but this, THIS, these poor, determined, hopeful people who have walked across a continent to get right here, raises your rage to the breaking point.

You need to save a dollar by starving a poor man while handing over twenty to a wealthy one with a smile and a music.

That you’d deny someone who has escaped hell on earth a blanket, a tv dinner, and a scrap of fitness center flooring to sleep on doesn’t make you a patriot. It makes you a nasty individual.

I stated good day, sir.


Catherynne M. Valente is a novelist; her latest ebook is Mass Effect: Annihilation.